Vintage (Pre-1990)
| My Little Pony - Mail Order MLP - Rapunzel - MO - Mint!
$599.95 My Little Pony - Mail Order MLP - Rapunzel - MO - Mint!
|
| OOAK Custom My Little Pony Wednesday Addams
$400.00 
OOAK Custom My Little Pony Wednesday Addams
|
| My Little Pony Playset Paradise Estate Complete with bo
$325.00
My Little Pony Playset Paradise Estate Complete with bo
|
| 1986 HASBRO MY LITTLE PONY SATIN SLIPPER SWEET SHOPPE
$249.95 1986 HASBRO MY LITTLE PONY SATIN SLIPPER SWEET SHOPPE
|
| ULTRA RARE MOC Little Pony ~*Surprise Twins Pony*~!
$249.90 $249.99
ULTRA RARE MOC Little Pony ~*Surprise Twins Pony*~!
|
| My Little Pony BIG BROTHERS, 9 Sets, RARE & Awesom!
$224.72 My Little Pony BIG BROTHERS, 9 Sets, RARE & Awesom!
|
| VERY RARE - G1 My Little Pony - Mimic
$179.00
VERY RARE - G1 My Little Pony - Mimic
|
| My Little Pony Party Pack MIB MIP NRFB VGC
$150.00 $200.00
My Little Pony Party Pack MIB MIP NRFB VGC
|
| Magenta Satin 'n Lace Wedding Mail Order My Little Pony
$150.00
Magenta Satin 'n Lace Wedding Mail Order My Little Pony
|
| MOONSTONE BLUE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK MOC MLP
$119.99 $149.99
MOONSTONE BLUE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK MOC MLP
|
| SUNLIGHT ORANGE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK MOC MLP
$119.99 $149.99
SUNLIGHT ORANGE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK MOC MLP
|
| STARSHINE WHITE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK MOC MLP
$119.99 $149.99
STARSHINE WHITE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK MOC MLP
|
| SUNLIGHT BLUE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK MOC MLP
$119.99 $149.99
SUNLIGHT BLUE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK MOC MLP
|
| My Little pony Dutch Baby Glory MIB
$100.00 My Little pony Dutch Baby Glory MIB
|
| MIB MOC Puddles & Peeks My Little Pony Newborn Twins
$99.99
MIB MOC Puddles & Peeks My Little Pony Newborn Twins
|
| My Little Pony mail order exclusive Li'l Cupcake baby
$99.99
My Little Pony mail order exclusive Li'l Cupcake baby
|
| My Little Pony mail order exclusive Li'l Sweetcake
$94.99
My Little Pony mail order exclusive Li'l Sweetcake
|
| RARE G1 My Little Pony Friend - Oakly the Moose
$89.00
RARE G1 My Little Pony Friend - Oakly the Moose
|
| Collection of 1980s's My Little Pony Hasbro Bradley!
$85.00
Collection of 1980s's My Little Pony Hasbro Bradley!
|
| Baby Sweet Tooth TAF Mail Order My Little Pony
$85.00
Baby Sweet Tooth TAF Mail Order My Little Pony
|
| Baby Milky Way TAF Mail Order My Little Pony
$85.00
Baby Milky Way TAF Mail Order My Little Pony
|
| 50 New DollSafe Display Case Boxes for My Little Ponies
$84.00
50 New DollSafe Display Case Boxes for My Little Ponies
|
| Lot of 23 Vintage My Little Ponies w Parlor, Stable Acc
$81.01 Lot of 23 Vintage My Little Ponies w Parlor, Stable Acc
|
| My Little pony Glory Nirvana Peru HTF
$81.00 My Little pony Glory Nirvana Peru HTF
|
| My Little Pony (G1) - Mummy Meadowsweet
$79.99 $105.00
My Little Pony (G1) - Mummy Meadowsweet
|
| Vintage 1983 My Little Pony Carry Case with 6 Ponies
$79.99
Vintage 1983 My Little Pony Carry Case with 6 Ponies
|
| Vintage 1983 My Little Pony Carry Case with 9 Ponies
$79.99
Vintage 1983 My Little Pony Carry Case with 9 Ponies
|
| My Little Pony MIB Purple talk-a-lot German MIP MOC
$79.95
My Little Pony MIB Purple talk-a-lot German MIP MOC
|
| Satin 'n Lace * So Soft My Little Pony * 426
$75.00
Satin 'n Lace * So Soft My Little Pony * 426
|
| MY LITTLEPONY VINTAGE-DIAMOND DREAMS MERRY GO ROUND
$74.99
MY LITTLEPONY VINTAGE-DIAMOND DREAMS MERRY GO ROUND
|
| MLP-My Little Pony Italian Sparkler - Ippolito-Rare HTF
$74.99
MLP-My Little Pony Italian Sparkler - Ippolito-Rare HTF
|
| My Little Pony -Mail Order - Blue Ribbon - Near Mint!
$74.95 $120.00
My Little Pony -Mail Order - Blue Ribbon - Near Mint!
|
| RARE BOWTIE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK G1 EXCELLENT MLP
$73.00 RARE BOWTIE MY LITTLE PONY GREEK G1 EXCELLENT MLP
|
| My Little Pony (G1) - Starlight
$69.99 $99.99
My Little Pony (G1) - Starlight
|
| My Little Pony (G1) - Beautiful Bows
$69.99 $99.99
My Little Pony (G1) - Beautiful Bows
|
| My Little Pony (G1) - Bangles
$69.99 $99.99
My Little Pony (G1) - Bangles
|
| MLP 2008 Euro FAIR EXCLUSIVE! - In sealed bag and box!
$69.99
MLP 2008 Euro FAIR EXCLUSIVE! - In sealed bag and box!
|
| RARE G1 My Little Pony - Baby Lucky Leaf and Pal Leafy
$69.00
RARE G1 My Little Pony - Baby Lucky Leaf and Pal Leafy
|
| MY LITTLE PONY HEART THROB-ULTRA RARE-MIP
$65.00
MY LITTLE PONY HEART THROB-ULTRA RARE-MIP
|
| 18 Vintage My Little Pony Lot ...A Must See Hard2Find
$65.00 $120.00
18 Vintage My Little Pony Lot ...A Must See Hard2Find
|
| MIB Drink'n Wet Baby Pony Baby Flicker, original Hasbro
$64.99
MIB Drink'n Wet Baby Pony Baby Flicker, original Hasbro
|
| Dutch Heart Pony, NM, original Hasbro, hard to find!
$64.99
Dutch Heart Pony, NM, original Hasbro, hard to find!
|
| My Little Pony - Princess Sparkle & Buggy - Near Mint
$63.95 My Little Pony - Princess Sparkle & Buggy - Near Mint
|
| My Little pony Argentina Glory #3 Very nice
$60.00 My Little pony Argentina Glory #3 Very nice
|
| My Little Pony vintage MAIL ORDER Baby BLUE RIBBON mint
$60.00
My Little Pony vintage MAIL ORDER Baby BLUE RIBBON mint
|
| MINTY My Little Pony IRISH SHAMROCK GREEN CLOVER
$58.45
MINTY My Little Pony IRISH SHAMROCK GREEN CLOVER
|
| MCDONALDS MY LITTLE PONY TRANSFORMER 1985 HASBRO
$55.00 MCDONALDS MY LITTLE PONY TRANSFORMER 1985 HASBRO
|
| My Little Pony lot - 5 Baby Ponies & Pretty Pals
$55.00
My Little Pony lot - 5 Baby Ponies & Pretty Pals
|
| MY LITTLE PONY NIRVANA HASBRO 83 TOP TOYS ARGENTINA
$54.99 MY LITTLE PONY NIRVANA HASBRO 83 TOP TOYS ARGENTINA
|
| The My Little Pony G1 G3 Collector's Inventory 2 Books
$54.99
The My Little Pony G1 G3 Collector's Inventory 2 Books
|
| Vintage Hasbro My Little Pony - G1 - 1987 - feathered
$51.17 Vintage Hasbro My Little Pony - G1 - 1987 - feathered
|
| My Little Pony MOC Rare Japan Rainbow Keychains JUN Co.
$50.00 My Little Pony MOC Rare Japan Rainbow Keychains JUN Co.
|
| Fairy Tails My Little Mini Pony GOLOSINA MIB, 1987
$50.00
Fairy Tails My Little Mini Pony GOLOSINA MIB, 1987
|
| My Little Pony 7 NIB Ponies & Playsets GREAT 4 GIFTS
$49.99 My Little Pony 7 NIB Ponies & Playsets GREAT 4 GIFTS
|
| My Little Pony~ Himmelstanzer~ HTF German Exclusive
$49.99 My Little Pony~ Himmelstanzer~ HTF German Exclusive
|
| My Little Pony~ Custom Mermaid: Minty's Nemesis~
$49.99 My Little Pony~ Custom Mermaid: Minty's Nemesis~
|
| My Little Pony Baby Palm Tree Pegasus First Tooth Rare!
$49.99
My Little Pony Baby Palm Tree Pegasus First Tooth Rare!
|
| HASBRO Lot of MY LITTLE PONY ponies 80s babies Moms ++
$49.99
HASBRO Lot of MY LITTLE PONY ponies 80s babies Moms ++
|
| Vintage G1 My Little Pony Big Brother SLUGGER w Hat MLP
$49.95
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Big Brother SLUGGER w Hat MLP
|
| VERY RARE G1 My Little Pony - pearlized baby firefly
$49.00
VERY RARE G1 My Little Pony - pearlized baby firefly
|
| VERY RARE G1 My Little Pony pearlized baby moondreamer
$49.00
VERY RARE G1 My Little Pony pearlized baby moondreamer
|
| VERY RARE G1 My Little Pony - windy wing Flurry
$49.00
VERY RARE G1 My Little Pony - windy wing Flurry
|
| VERY RARE G1 My Little Pony - baby princess sparkle
$49.00
VERY RARE G1 My Little Pony - baby princess sparkle
|
| My Little Pony - International - Sparks the Dragon - VG
$47.95 $64.00
My Little Pony - International - Sparks the Dragon - VG
|
| MY LITTLE PONY VINTAGE DREAM CASTLE MAJESTY ACCESSORIES
$46.00 MY LITTLE PONY VINTAGE DREAM CASTLE MAJESTY ACCESSORIES
|
| MLP-My Little Pony Flower Fantasy *Love Petal* w Brush
$45.99
MLP-My Little Pony Flower Fantasy *Love Petal* w Brush
|
| MLP-My Little Pony Colorswirl ****Lovebeam**** w Comb
$45.99
MLP-My Little Pony Colorswirl ****Lovebeam**** w Comb
|
| Baby Leaper * Vintage My Little Pony 106
$45.00
Baby Leaper * Vintage My Little Pony 106
|
| Moon Jumper * Windy Wing My Little Pony * 426
$45.00
Moon Jumper * Windy Wing My Little Pony * 426
|
| MLP-My Little Pony Flower Fantasy Sweet Blossom w Brush
$44.99
MLP-My Little Pony Flower Fantasy Sweet Blossom w Brush
|
| My Little pony Italy Italian Glory #2
$40.00 My Little pony Italy Italian Glory #2
|
| The My Little Pony G1 Collector's Inventory Price Guide
$39.99
The My Little Pony G1 Collector's Inventory Price Guide
|
| The My Little Pony G1 Collector's Inventory Guide Book
$39.99
The My Little Pony G1 Collector's Inventory Guide Book
|
| MLPONY VINTAGE-MERRY TREAT & CHRISTMAS BABY COMB
$39.99
MLPONY VINTAGE-MERRY TREAT & CHRISTMAS BABY COMB
|
| Vintage My Little Pony Angel So Soft pony VHTF
$39.99
Vintage My Little Pony Angel So Soft pony VHTF
|
| My Little Pony - Large MLP Lot of 40 - Very Good to CB
$39.95 $110.00
My Little Pony - Large MLP Lot of 40 - Very Good to CB
|
| RARE VINTAGE G1 MAIL ORDER MY LITTLE PONY GOLDILOCKS
$39.95
RARE VINTAGE G1 MAIL ORDER MY LITTLE PONY GOLDILOCKS
|
| VTG G1 MY LITTLE PONY COMPLETE "LULLABY NURSERY" w BOX
$39.95 VTG G1 MY LITTLE PONY COMPLETE "LULLABY NURSERY" w BOX
|
| MY LITTLE PONY 1987 Stickers - Box w 50 SEALED packets
$39.95
MY LITTLE PONY 1987 Stickers - Box w 50 SEALED packets
|
| Princess Tiffany & Bushwoolie Friendly My Little Pony
$39.95
Princess Tiffany & Bushwoolie Friendly My Little Pony
|
| Tux 'n Tails * Vintage My Little Pony
$39.95
Tux 'n Tails * Vintage My Little Pony
|
| 20 New DollSafe Display Case Boxes for My Little Ponies
$39.20
20 New DollSafe Display Case Boxes for My Little Ponies
|
| RARE G1 My Little Pony - pearlized baby cotton candy
$39.00
RARE G1 My Little Pony - pearlized baby cotton candy
|
| lot of three Cookery Ponies, original Hasbro, htf!
$38.99
lot of three Cookery Ponies, original Hasbro, htf!
|
| My Little Pony (G1) - Seaspray
$35.00 $45.00
My Little Pony (G1) - Seaspray
|
| My Little pony Argentina Glory #1
$35.00 My Little pony Argentina Glory #1
|
| My Little pony Italian Glory
$35.00 My Little pony Italian Glory
|
| My Little pony Lot of Glory ponies Galore
$35.00 My Little pony Lot of Glory ponies Galore
|
| My Little Pony- UK Surprise Twins Mommy
$35.00 My Little Pony- UK Surprise Twins Mommy
|
| My Little Pony porcelain collectibles
$35.00 My Little Pony porcelain collectibles
|
| MY LITTLE PONY MOMMY CHARMS HAPPY DANCER PONY
$35.00
MY LITTLE PONY MOMMY CHARMS HAPPY DANCER PONY
|
| Sun Glider * Windy Wing My Little Pony * 426
$35.00
Sun Glider * Windy Wing My Little Pony * 426
|
| My Little Pony - Flutter - Rosedust - Mint with Wings!
$34.95 $65.00
My Little Pony - Flutter - Rosedust - Mint with Wings!
|
| Princess Moondust * Year 6 My Little Pony * 978
$34.95
Princess Moondust * Year 6 My Little Pony * 978
|
| Mommy Sunbright, mint condition! vhtf! original Hasbro
$32.99
Mommy Sunbright, mint condition! vhtf! original Hasbro
|
| 1980's My Little Pony Summer Wing Pony Glow MLP
$31.99
1980's My Little Pony Summer Wing Pony Glow MLP
|
| My Little pony Argentina Glory #2
$30.00 My Little pony Argentina Glory #2
|
| My Little pony Lot of Glory Items party stuff and more
$30.00 My Little pony Lot of Glory Items party stuff and more
|
| My Little Pony HTF Fashion Star Sassy SixTeens Janel
$30.00
My Little Pony HTF Fashion Star Sassy SixTeens Janel
|
| My Little Pony HTF Fashion Star Sassy SixTeens Corrinne
$30.00
My Little Pony HTF Fashion Star Sassy SixTeens Corrinne
|
